Week 7 Blog Assignment: Neuroscience + Art

 In the Introduction Lecture, Professor Vesna raises the question of whether machines are expanding our consciousness or if we are becoming slaves to machines as they begin to think for us. When looking at the correlation with art, I personally believe that this argument can go both ways as machines have allowed us to expand the genres, mediums, and possibilities of art whilst making it very easy to utilize as a tool for creating ideas rather than thinking of those ideas on your own. Professor Vesna’s Octopus Brainstorming performative installation is an example of a form of art that would not be possible without the use of machines showing how new art forms can be created with the integration of machines. On the other hand, the convenient access to these machines as well as the content within these machines have also given us a way to become reliant on these machines which can become a hindrance on an artist’s own creativity.

Source: https://decrypt.co/210437/human-reference-people-art-over-ai-creations-study

Another question that can be raised is whether or not art created by Artificial Intelligence is considered art. One article mentions that people prefer human-made art over AI-made art but they fail to see the difference between the two different forms as “new research shows that AI images are already good enough that people are often unable to differentiate between it and art created by humans.” (Lanz 2023) Another article states how future art will rely on Artificial Intelligence since it automates and augments human capabilities. However, in this same article, it does mention that “the line between what’s made by humans and what’s made by machines is getting blurrier” which forces people “to rethink…ideas about creativity and ownership in the arts” and “stir[s] up ethical questions about the integrity of art and what it means for something to be created genuinely.” (Persie 2024) The inability to differentiate between art created by humans versus art created by machines as well as the blurring of the lines between these two different forms of art makes it difficult to determine the genesis of the art and if humans have been influenced by AI or if AI has been influenced by humans.

Most People can’t distinguish between AI and human art, a new study says

Source: https://www.dazeddigital.com/art-photography/article/52030/1/people-cant-distinguish-between-ai-artificial-intelligence-human-art-new-study

Another issue that can be raised is individuals taking on other people’s art as their own idea due to the oversaturation of art that is easily accessible through the medium of a machine. There was this one current event where a Luxembourg painter painted the same exact image of a photographer’s photograph and won a cash prize for that painting. Although this instance does not directly involve the use of machines in the production of the art itself, the machine became the medium in which the painter was able to view the photograph and paint it as his own work. This is another example in which machines make it very easy to be utilized as a tool for creating ideas rather than thinking of those ideas on your own; in this case, copying ideas. These varying examples on machines and art reinforce the question of if we are becoming heavily reliant on machines that we lose consciousness of the origins of ideas and memory.

Source: https://www.zhangjingna.com/blog/luxembourg-copyright-case-win-against-jeff-dieschburg

References

Goetz, Marco. “Luxembourg Copyright Case against Jeff Dieschburg - Jingna Zhang Fashion, Fine Art & Beauty Photography.” Jingna Zhang, Jingna Zhang, 10 May 2024, www.zhangjingna.com/blog/luxembourg-copyright-case-win-against-jeff-dieschburg.

L, Persie, “Why Will Future Art Rely on Machine Intelligence?” iPic Free Ai Image Generator, 1 Apr. 2024, www.ipic.ai/blogs/why-will-future-art-rely-on-machine-intelligence/. 

Lanz, Jose Antonio. “Art of Confusion: Humans Prefer ‘real’ Art to AI Art, but Struggle to Tell the Difference.” Decrypt, Decrypt, 20 Dec. 2023, decrypt.co/210437/human-reference-people-art-over-ai-creations-study.

Mineo, Liz. “Is Art Generated by Artificial Intelligence Real Art?” Harvard Gazette, 8 Feb. 2024, news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/08/is-art-generated-by-artificial-intelligence-real-art/.

Vesna, Victoria. “Neuroscience + Art Lecture Intro.”

Waite Thom. “Most People Can’t Distinguish between AI and Human Art, Says a New Study.” Dazed, 25 Feb. 2021, www.dazeddigital.com/art-photography/article/52030/1/people-cant-distinguish-between-ai-artificial-intelligence-human-art-new-study.


Comments

  1. Hello Melody,
    I really enjoyed reading your blog. I particularly like how you highlight both the potential expansion of artistic possibilities through technology and the risks of over-reliance on machines, potentially stifling individual creativity.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Melody,

    I thought you brought up a great point with whether or not art can be created with AI. This is especially relevant in recent times with continuing updates to new generative technology. I also think it really ties into with what Dr. Vesna said about if it's inevitable that machines will start to think for us. I also really liked your perspective about how this new accessibility of creating art may decrease individuality and maybe even lead to more theft.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Melody,
    Thank you for your thoughtful response to the material. I thought that your blog was extremely interesting. The discussion of AI generated art caught my attention a lot. I work at a marketing company and we use AI generated art all the time to post on instagram and to make news letters. It is so much more convenient and efficient than having someone have to make every single piece we use. Although it is easier to use AI generated art I also would say I prefer art that I know is made my a person. I think this because I know the art is intentional and conveys some kinda of meaning to the artist. But your discussion made me realize that I honestly cant tell the difference between AI generated art and Human art.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment